The Safe, Secret Ingredient To Elevate Homemade Bavarian Soft Pretzels - The Daily Meal (2024)

Facts Food Science

The Safe, Secret Ingredient To Elevate Homemade Bavarian Soft Pretzels - The Daily Meal (1)

Evgeny Karandaev/Shutterstock

ByChase Shustack|

A soft pretzel, at its most basic, is strikingly similar to bread dough that's been tied into a distinct shape, baked until golden brown, and topped with salt. But somehow, perhaps through some culinary miracle, the whole thing just works. It is one of life's many little joys to dig into a warm soft pretzel, with its salty crunchy exterior and pillowy soft interior that's perfect for dipping into mustard or beer cheese. Whether you microwave them or bake them, nothing beats a good soft pretzel.

Perhaps the type of soft pretzel most people are familiar with is the Bavarian soft pretzel. The reason we associate pretzels with German culture is thanks to the pretzel's connections with the early Catholic Church in medieval Europe. According to The Grenchus Foundation, Germans fasting during the Lent season created the pretzel as a way to eat without breaking their fast, with the unique symbol of the pretzel being said to represent the Holy Trinity. Some sources, such as GermanFoods, tell us that pretzels were invented by a monk to reward children for their daily prayer lessons, with the "arms" of the pretzel resembling a child's hands crossed in prayer. Whatever the reason, the Bavarian soft pretzel, with its crunchy exterior and soft interior, is viewed as one of the quintessential types of soft pretzels to try.

If you're making Bavarian soft pretzels at home, there's one ingredient that you probably shouldn't skip over to get the best pretzel you can.

An alkaline solution helps gives the pretzels their flavor

The Safe, Secret Ingredient To Elevate Homemade Bavarian Soft Pretzels - The Daily Meal (2)

Tada Images/Shutterstock

If pretzels and bread have very similar ingredients, have you ever wondered what gives pretzels their distinct flavor? According to Food and Wine, the unique pretzel flavor comes from the pretzel being washed in an alkaline solution such as baking soda before being baked. But how does alkaline solution give you that unique flavor?

Chef Billy Parsi details that, when you "parboil," or boil your pretzels in a solution before baking, you're allowing the mixture of baking soda and water to "gelatinize" the dough. The baking soda, which is known for its neutralizing and cleaning abilities thanks to it being sodium bicarbonate (via Farmer's Almanac), reacts with the dough, giving it a soft and airy interior and a crisp, golden crust on the exterior.

Food and Wine elaborates that, should you find yourself wanting a much richer flavor that is more traditional of Bavarian pretzels, you should first bake your baking soda before adding it to your mixture. Heating your baking soda lowers its pH level and makes it more acidic, thus heightening its properties. The New York Times offers similar advice, explaining that "baked" baking soda is also a key ingredient in dishes such as Chinese alkaline noodles.

But you may remember that we said this is a "safe" ingredient. What exactly did we mean by that, and what is the "riskier" alternative to baking soda?

You could also use food-grade lye.

The Safe, Secret Ingredient To Elevate Homemade Bavarian Soft Pretzels - The Daily Meal (3)

Kittisak Kaewchalun /Getty Images

You may have seen lye used in soaps or to dissolve other chemicals. In fact, you may have even heard of certain reports of people being burned by the substance, such as one woman in 2013 (via CBS News). SA Health tells us that lye can be extremely dangerous if consumed or splashed on the skin, giving extremely painful and severe burns. Why, then, would such a substance be used in cooking and in pretzels of all things?

According to King Arthur Baking, lye and caustic sodas are used in the process of baking pretzels because lye's reaction to the pretzels, much like baking soda, gives them that chewy texture, light interior, and brown crust. King Arthur does admit, of course, that lye can be dangerous if used in the wrong hands, but there are many safety precautions one can take to ensure that it is being used in a professional and responsible manner. This includes using food-grade lye, wearing proper attire, working in well-ventilated areas, and thorough clean-up and disposal. While lye is dangerous, it can become no more dangerous than a kitchen knife or stove when used responsibly and with caution in mind.

If you're still worried about using lye in your home, baking soda can give you the classic pretzel taste you're looking for without much of the risk.

Recommended

The Safe, Secret Ingredient To Elevate Homemade Bavarian Soft Pretzels - The Daily Meal (2024)

FAQs

The Safe, Secret Ingredient To Elevate Homemade Bavarian Soft Pretzels - The Daily Meal? ›

Food and Wine elaborates that, should you find yourself wanting a much richer flavor that is more traditional of Bavarian pretzels, you should first bake your baking soda before adding it to your mixture. Heating your baking soda lowers its pH level and makes it more acidic, thus heightening its properties.

What is the secret ingredient which makes a pretzel taste like a pretzel? ›

The answer lies in a brief dip in an alkaline water bath before baking. This bath essentially gelatinizes the outside of the pretzel, preventing it from fully “springing” during baking (as bread does) and giving pretzels their signature chewy crust. It also gives them their unique and indelible “pretzel” flavor.

What is the difference between a Bavarian pretzel and a soft pretzel? ›

Unlike their American counterpart, Bavarian pretzels pack a denser, chewier inside and a darker, crispier outside. And there's a certain "tang" to the Bavarian-style pretzel that sets it apart from other soft pretzels. But best of all, it doesn't need to be dipped in cheese or drenched in butter to taste delicious!

Is baking soda or lye better for pretzels? ›

That said, if sourcing and handling lye isn't for you, you can use a simmering baking soda solution instead. With a pH of roughly 8.3, it reacts less than lye and yields pretzels that are lighter in color and flavor, but the results are still impressive.

What to use instead of lye for pretzels? ›

The most benign substitute for lye is baking soda. You'll get a little bit of browning and some chew, but don't expect it to taste very pretzel-y. You can also used baked baking soda, which is a stronger alkali than baking soda but not as caustic as lye.

What gives soft pretzels their flavor? ›

What Gives Pretzels Their Pretzel Flavor? You have baking soda to thank for that distinct pretzel flavor. Baking soda is highly alkaline and imparts that subtly metallic taste onto the dough before your pretzels go into the oven. Some recipes call for a lye bath, which does the same thing.

Why do my homemade pretzels taste weird? ›

If your pretzels have any sort of a metallic, bitter taste, it all comes down to the baking soda bath.

What do Germans eat with soft pretzels? ›

The popular toppings of authentic bavarian pretzels are:

Sesame, poppy, sunflower, pumpkin or caraway seeds, cheese sauce and bacon bits. Bavarians especially enjoy their pretzels in the late morning with Weißwürst, sweet mustard, and a Beer.

What is a Bavarian pretzel made of? ›

German pretzels are usually made with little more than bread flour, water, yeast (or a sourdough culture), salt, and fat like butter or lard. (According to Heike, the latter is traditional in Bavaria, though butter is an acceptable choice nowadays.)

What does baking soda do for soft pretzels? ›

As noted above, baking soda is a staple ingredient for making homemade pretzels. Dunking your pretzels in a baking soda bath prior to baking is what enables them to develop their distinctive color and crispy-on-the-outside, chewy-on-the-inside texture.

Is it safe to eat pretzels dipped in lye? ›

Once lye-dipped pretzels are baked, they're totally safe (and delicious!) to eat.

What is a safe substitute for lye? ›

In this method, you're replacing lye with baking soda, both of which are alkalies. However, lye is much stronger than baking soda. Heating up baking soda in the oven turns it from sodium bicarbonate into sodium carbonate, making it a slightly stronger alkali that'll better replace the lye.

Is sodium hydroxide safe in food? ›

The sodium hydroxide in our products is food-grade and designated as safe for general use in food by the FDA1. Sodium hydroxide has been widely used in drinking water as a pH adjusting agent and is also used in food processing. It has a long history of safe use in these applications.

How long to soak pretzels in lye? ›

Carefully sprinkle the lye into the water. Use a heat-safe silicone spatula to carefully stir the lye to dissolve. The lye is dissolved when the water looks clear (the container will feel warm to the touch – this is normal). Dip a shaped pretzel into the lye bath for about 30 seconds.

What makes a pretzel roll taste like a pretzel? ›

Lye-dipped pretzels, or in this case, pretzel buns, have a distinctive flavour that is both savoury and slightly bitter. The lye, a strong alkaline solution, is used to give the pretzels their characteristic dark brown colour and chewy exterior.

What is the secret solution for Auntie Anne's pretzels? ›

Whisk together 2 cups (454 grams) of warm water and the 1/3 cup (90 grams) baking soda in a shallow dish. Dip the pretzels into the baking soda bath. Flip and dip the other side. Place the dipped pretzels onto a parchment-lined baking sheet.

What is the flavor profile of pretzels? ›

Tasting Notes:

The typical pretzel has a pleasant cracker-like flavor, a crisp, brittle texture and a brown glossy surface color. Salt crystals are often sprinkled on its surface to make them taste more appealing. Pretzels have a moisture content of anywhere from 2-4% and therefore have a very long shelf life.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Velia Krajcik

Last Updated:

Views: 6378

Rating: 4.3 / 5 (54 voted)

Reviews: 85% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Velia Krajcik

Birthday: 1996-07-27

Address: 520 Balistreri Mount, South Armand, OR 60528

Phone: +466880739437

Job: Future Retail Associate

Hobby: Polo, Scouting, Worldbuilding, Cosplaying, Photography, Rowing, Nordic skating

Introduction: My name is Velia Krajcik, I am a handsome, clean, lucky, gleaming, magnificent, proud, glorious person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.